Not Normal™

Not Normal is returning. 🖤

One of our most loved past color stories is coming back in a new, more compact format. The original 18-shade Not Normal color story remains the same, now featuring our new talc-free matte formula and smaller 15 mm pans.

This edition will no longer feature magnetic pans. By moving select past releases into this smaller format, we're able to keep color stories that are special to us available while reducing the amount of warehouse space they require and offering them at a much lower price.

This smaller format is reserved for select palettes that have been part of Unearthly for over two years. All Future Unearthly palettes will continue to feature our full-size 22.7mm magnetic pans.

PLEASE NOTE: This is a demand-based preorder. If we do not receive enough orders to meet the minimum production quantity, Not Normal will be canceled and all orders will be fully refunded.

Estimated Shipping: End of October – Early November 2026

We’ve given ourselves additional production time so we can provide a realistic shipping window and avoid unnecessary delays.

1. Day Job: A warm caramel matte that blends effortlessly, providing a smooth base or subtle crease definition for natural looks.
2. Topaz: A gleaming yellow-gold shimmer with strong metallic reflectivity, adding a luxurious touch of brightness.
3. Curious: A rich mustard matte, perfect for grounding your look with a bold transition or as a statement crease color.
4. Gemini: A glowing pastel lime shimmer, reflecting hints of silver and yellow for a light-catching, airy finish.
5. Sultry: A deep matte purple with soft, velvety coverage, ideal for creating a moody and dramatic lid or smoky effect.
6. Impulsive: A bright violet shimmer with a luminous magenta sparkle, high-impact finish, featuring multi-dimensional purple reflects.
7. Basic: A soft cream matte, blending smoothly into the skin to highlight or diffuse edges for seamless transitions.
8. Emerald: A vivid true green matte with an intense, opaque payoff, delivering bold color that’s striking and versatile.
9. Charisma: A teal-green shimmer with a metallic, aqua-blue shift, making it a show-stopping, multidimensional shade.
10. Excorcise: A brilliant, punchy sunflower yellow matte with full coverage, perfect for an energetic and vibrant pop of color.
11. Taupe: A taupe shimmer with a soft, bronze finish, adding a sophisticated, neutral metallic look with subtle warmth.
12. Believer: A deep, mossy olive green matte, bringing an earthy, grounded feel to your eye look with great depth.
13. Smoke: A dark, cool-toned brown matte that works perfectly for adding dimension, deepening the crease, or lining the eyes.
14. Emotions: A soft, iridescent lavender shimmer with pink and silver highlights, providing a delicate yet impactful glow.
15. Sage: A muted pastel sage green matte, blending softly to create a subtle wash of color, perfect for understated looks.
16. Mood Swing: A lilac shimmer with frosty lavender and silver reflects, giving off a cool-toned, icy finish with a touch of glam.
17. Grunge: A deep, rusty brown matte with warm, reddish undertones, perfect for creating intense, grunge-inspired eye looks.
18. Soft Spot: A dusty rose matte with a hint of mauve, ideal for adding a soft, romantic flush to the eyes or as a transition shade.